Investigations

One Health analysis in Plentzia
Plentzia Estuary, Biscay
Case Studies Biscay

Introduction

The risk of infection from bacteria and viruses present in bathing waters depends on many factors. Not everyone is exposed in the same way, not everyone who comes into contact with these germs falls ill, and not everyone has the same recovery capacity. These variations depend not only on the presence of germs in the water, which can be amplified by climate change and pollution, but also on people’s health status and their access to the economic and social support needed to cope with illness.

Understanding how environmental, health, and social factors interact allows us to identify vulnerable groups, key environmental pressures and to better reduce disease risks. In Plentzia Bay and the Butroe River estuary, BlueAdapt teams from BC3 and PiE-EHU carried out an integrated analysis using a One Health approach, bringing together knowledge from different fields to provide a complete picture of these complex challenges.

This map shoes the Butroe River estuary and Plentzia Bay.
This is a study map of the Butroe River estuary and Plentzia Bay. It integrates natural and urban areas alongside key infrastructure, such as the Marine Station of Plentzia (PiE-EHU), the wastewater treatment plant, and healthcare centres as well as sampling sites for water and marine biodiversity. Author: Andrea Albert-Fonseca (2025).

 

Why is the One Health approach important?

Today’s public health challenges are deeply connected with environmental changes and social inequalities. When we analyze these issues in isolation, we may miss how they reinforce each other, leaving out critical pieces of the puzzle.

The One Health approach provides an overarching framework to bring these dimensions together:

  • Reduces blind spots: It highlights the knowledge gaps and promotes combining evidence from different topics to prevent isolated decisions that might address one problem while aggravating another.
  • Uncovers shared opportunities: By focusing on the links between the factors that intensify health- and environmental challenges, it also highlights the common ground in addressing these challenges, helping to identify “win-win” points of intervention across different sectors.
  • Reflects real-world complexity: In the Plentzia Bay and Butroe Estuary, this approach connects environmental pressures (such as warming waters and polluted run-off) with social and economic factors (like seasonal tourism, age, pre-existing chronic conditions, poor mental health, social inequalities).

How did we do the investigation?

Researchers conducted a collaborative study between different research expertise to identify the key environmental, public health and social pressures affecting the community in Plentzia Bay.

We combined multiple methods and data sources, including:

  1. Environmental research and laboratory analysis: Sampling coastal waters and marine species to trace microbiological and chemical contamination and spatial data analysis.
  2. Social and health research: Conducting interviews and surveys with local stakeholders alongside literature reviews and spatial data analysis.

Rather than analysing each piece in isolation, we focused on how the factors interact and identify feedback loops, this helped us to pinpoint hotspots and to grasp the reality underneath the data.

What did we find?

Environmental pressures

  1. Seasonal impacts: Pressures fluctuate significantly throughout the year, driven by summer tourism spikes.
  2. Specific estuary risks: Key threats identified include algal blooms, non-native invasive species, and the entry of agricultural or urban run-off in the estuary and the bay following intense rainfall events.

Knowledge gaps

  1. Community insights: Interviews with local health experts and residents and visitors of Plentzia Bay show a gap between research priorities and everyday realities on the ground. While research emphasises long-term threats like climate change and antimicrobial resistance (AMR), local health professionals view aging populations, chronic patients care and mental health as immediate priorities. Residents and visitors focus more on tangible sensory aesthetic cues like rubbish, water clarity, and smells, rather than on threats like heatwaves and water scarcity.
  2. Data limitations: Information remains limited regarding local infectious diseases, chronic illnesses, lifestyle, and health behaviors. Additionally, not enough is known yet about how pathogens transmit through recreational water activities or seafood consumption.
  3. Baseline for future research: The study established a baseline of future research in the area. Based on these results researchers can now zoom in on specific issues.

Societal impact

All the data collected to understand the main challenges in this case study forms the basis for informing Plentzia Bay’s novel One Health Living Lab (OHLL).

This Living Lab is a pilot initiative implemented in the study area. It builds an alliance among relevant and diverse local stakeholders to forge a joint effort in addressing One Health challenges in the local region. The OHLL fosters collaboration among researchers from different disciplines, communication across various institutions and sectors, knowledge exchange with the local community, and a better understanding of how science can strengthen community resilience and adaptation capacity.

Follow the Living Lab

External collaborators

Municipal governments, healthcare actors, public health services, water agency and water management company, NGOs, tourism entrepreneurs and citizens groups.

Share this research